Human Rights at NCKU

Showing posts with label Court Appeal. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 25, 2010

Second Appeal to the Court Regarding the Illegal Dismissal at National Cheng Kung University in Tainan, Taiwan

Posted by Human Rights at a Taiwan University at 3:28 AM No comments:

Email This BlogThis!Share to X Share to Facebook Share to Pinterest

Labels: August 25 2010, Court Appeal

Older Posts Home

Subscribe to: Posts (Atom)

Followers

Blog Archive

▼ 2011 (17)
- ▼ May (2)
  - Fwd: A formal appeal for the resignation of the cu...
  - Fwd: Regarding the National Cheng Kung Web Site
- ► April (2)
- ► March (10)
- ► February (2)
- ► January (1)

► 2010 (309)
- ► November (11)
- ► October (4)
- ► September (2)
- ► August (172)
- ► July (120)

► 2009 (6)
- ► December (1)
- ► November (1)
- ► October (2)
- ► August (1)
- ► July (1)

► 2008 (1)
- ► August (1)

► 2007 (1)
- ► December (1)

► 2001 (1)
- ► June (1)

About Me

Human Rights at a Taiwan University: I formerly taught at National Cheng Kung University in Tainan, Taiwan. I was illegally dismissed in 1999 and won an appeal at the Ministry of Education in Taipei in 2001, but the university refused to enforce that ruling for nearly 2 1/2 years. Since then the university has neither compensated me nor apologized for human rights abuses, which included circulating a secret letter at committee hearings, constantly changing its reasons for the dismissal action, claiming that foreign teachers are not protected by the Teacher's Law that protects Taiwan teachers, and then, despite participating in appeal hearings at both the university and MOE levels, saying that foreigners had no right to appeal. Despite these violations National Cheng Kung University maintains numerous academic exchanges with universities in the US and in other democracies.

View my complete profile

HUMAN RIGHTS ABUSES AT NATIONAL CHENG KUNG UNIVERSITY IN TAINAN, TAIWAN

The blog you are reading was set up to expose human rights violations at National Cheng Kung University in Tainan, Taiwan, beginning with an illegal dismissal in March 1999 that included a secret letter solicited from a student (conveniently dated the day before a department dismissal hearing). I was allowed to see that letter only after taking the student to court. (The student, incidentally, not only has, to this day, not been punished, but was subsequently hired to teach at NCKU university!)

That letter was circulated at numerous so-called "oversight" (i.e. "review" and "appeal") hearings at the university, which, despite warnings from the NCKU Faculty Union, finalized the dismissal, which was ultimately overturned by the Ministry of Education Appeals Committee (8 January 2001), a ruling that bold-faced human rights violations in pedagogic style.

The university defied that legal MOE ruling for nearly 2 1/2 years. It argued, instead, that 1. Foreigners are not protected by the Teacher's Law and, 2. Despite the fact that the university held appeal hearings and participated at appeal hearings at the Ministry hearings in Taipei, foreigners have no right to appeal!

To this day the university seems to be in a state of denial that it did anything wrong. It has neither apologized for wrongdoing, offered compensation, punished officials responsible, or attempted remedial action to prevent a recurrence of such misconduct.

To this day NCKU officials have acted with impunity. In fact the NCKU president who refused to obey the Ministry ruling, despite 8 MOE warning letters to do so, was subsequently reappointed to another 3-year term as university president.

To this day, to my knowledge at least, not a single faculty member in my department has protested my treatment here. Certainly there has been no organized protest in support of my human rights here. (In Mainland China they stand up to moving tanks.) Yet NCKU is presumably the fourth-ranked university in Taiwan and has numerous academic exchanges with American universities and universities in other democracies.

The letters mainly focus on my illegal dismissal and the failure of NCKU officials to enforce a legal Ministry appeal ruling. (One must assume that a Ministry ruling is legal or it would be pointless not only to have an appeal but to have a Ministry!) However I've included some letters regarding the student who wrote a secret defamatory letter against me, so readers can see the difficulty of administrative remedy at our university. This student's SECRET letter was accepted immediately, resulting in my dismissal, I believe, in two weeks. My numerous petitions to punish her have been ignored for more than ten years! In sum, in a secret letter that was then circulated through several so-called oversight committees ("review" and "appeal" at the "college" and "university" levels), this student argued I failed her unfairly 8 years before. How can a student contest a grade 8 years later? And in secret? Besides, she received 3 other reasonably high passes from me the same year. Where's the logic? Is there another university in the world that would accredit such an accusation, eight years later, without proof, made in secret, and denying the right of the teacher to even learn about the accusation much less defend himself against it (I read the student's letter only after taking her to court!).

Navigating this web site can be made easier by referring to the labels at the bottom of the page with words or phrases that key the substance of each post.

Labels

2003 (2)
A Few Truly Good Changes (1)
Academic Exchanges (1)
Advisory Council for Human Rights (1)
Aesop (1)
American Association of University Professors (2)
Annette Lu (2)
April 1 2004 (1)
April 21 2007 (2)
April 22 2010 (1)
April 23 2002 (1)
April 23 2010 (2)
April 24 2002 (4)
April 24 2003 (1)
April 28 2003 (2)
April 4 2004 (1)
Asian Research (1)
August 1 2002 (1)
August 14 2000 (1)
August 15 2000 (1)
August 15 2006 (1)
August 16 2000 (2)
August 16 2001 (1)
August 16 2003 (2)
August 19 2002 (1)
August 23 2000 (1)
August 24 2001 (1)
August 24 2004 (1)
August 25 2000 (1)
August 25 2010 (2)
August 26 2003 (1)
August 26 2010 (1)
August 3 2010 (1)
August 30 2003 (2)
August 4 2003 (1)
August 5 2003 (1)
August 5 2010 (2)
August 6 (1)
August 7 2003 (1)
August 7 2010 (5)
August 9 2003 (2)
Brian Kennedy (2)
Bruce Jacobs (1)
C. C. Chang (1)
Cary Nelson (1)
Chen An-Chun Secret Letter Case (1)
Chinese Association for Human Rights (1)
Chronological Summary (3)
Columbia University (1)
Committee Hearing (1)
Control Yuan (5)
Court Appeal (1)
Court Appeal Regarding the Case of the Illegal Dismissal at National Cheng Kung University (1)
Court Deposition on the Lily Chen Case (1)
Court Testimony on the Lily Chen Case (1)
Court Verdict (1)
Dahtong Ray (3)
Dean Ko Huei-chen (26)
Dean of Student Affairs (35)
December 10 2001 (1)
December 11 2003 (1)
December 12 2001 (1)
December 12 2003 (1)
December 15 2003 (1)
December 15 2006 (1)
December 16 2003 (1)
December 17 2003 (1)
December 20 2003 (1)
December 21 2007 (1)
December 27 2000 (1)
December 3 2002 (1)
December 6 2001 (1)
December 7 2005 (1)
December 7 2007 (1)
Department of Academic Freedom and Tenure (1)
Dismissal Letter from Chairman Ren Shyh-jong. (1)
Email from a Colleague about Student Misconduct (1)
Fable (1)
February 11 2004 (1)
February 12 2004 (1)
February 13 2003 (1)
February 13 2004 (1)
February 15 2004 (1)
February 16 2004 (1)
February 17 2004 (1)
February 18 2004 (1)
February 19 2004 (1)
February 20 2002 (2)
February 20 2004 (1)
February 2001 (1)
February 22 2002 (2)
February 23 2004 (2)
February 26 2002 (1)
February 27 2002 (3)
February 28 2002 (1)
Foreigners Not Protected by the Teacher's Law (1)
From the Office of the Secretariat (1)
Human Rights Advisory Watch (1)
Human Rights in Taiwan (3)
Human Rights Lesson in Picture Format (1)
Human Rights Watch (1)
Humanistic Education Foundation (2)
Humanities Education Foundation (2)
January 11 2008 (1)
January 14 2008 (2)
January 16 2006 (1)
January 18 2007 (1)
January 23 2003 (2)
January 24 2004 (1)
January 28 2004 (2)
January 29 2004 (1)
January 9 2003 (1)
Jen Ko-jiang (1)
John McCain Quote (1)
Judicial Reform Committee (1)
Judicial Watch (1)
July 10 2003 (1)
July 11 2003 (1)
July 13 2003 (1)
July 14 2003 (2)
July 15 2003 (3)
July 15 2010 (2)
July 16 2002 (2)
July 17 2002 (3)
July 17 2003 (1)
July 18 2003 (3)
July 19 2010 (1)
July 20 2003 (3)
July 21 2003 (2)
July 22 2003 (2)
July 22 2004 (1)
July 23 2003 (2)
July 24 2003 (1)
July 24 2009 (1)
July 25 2001 (2)
July 27 2010 (2)
July 29 2002 (1)
July 3 2001 (1)
July 30 2010 (1)
July 31 2002 (1)
July 9 2003 (4)
June 11 2003 (1)
June 12 2003 (2)
June 15 2003 (1)
June 16 2001 (1)
June 16 2003 (1)
June 24 2005 (2)
June 24 2006 (1)
June 26 2003 (1)
June 28 2003 (1)
June 28 2004 (2)
June 6 2001 (1)
June 7 2007 (1)
June 8 2010 (1)
June 9 2003 (2)
Kao Chiang (42)
Lai Chung-hsiung (1)
Lai Ming-Chiao (12)
Lee Yuan Tseh (1)
Legal Profession's Silence (1)
Letter Concerning Human Rights Abuses at National Cheng Kung University (1)
Letter from Office of Student Affairs (1)
Letter to Academia Sinica (1)
Letter to Chou Chih-Chieh (1)
Letter to colleague who ran for Dean of Liberal Arts (1)
Letter to FLLD Colleagues 2006 (2)
Letter to FLLD Colleagues 2009 (1)
Letter to FLLD Colleagues Sept 28 2007 (1)
Letter to Hwung-Hweng Hwung (1)
Letter to Judicial Reform Foundation (1)
Letter to Kaohsiung City Council (1)
Letter to Lin Feng-jeng (1)
Letter to Ministry of Education (1)
Letter to National Cheng Kung University (1)
Letter to P (1)
Letter to Purdue University (2)
Letter to Student World Assembly (1)
Letter to The Associated Press (1)
Letter to the Department (4)
Letter to the District Attorney (trans.) (2)
Letter to The Exponent of Purdue University (2)
Letter to the Ministry of Education (2)
Letter to The Taipei Times (2)
Letter to University Accrediation Agency (5)
Letters from the Ministry of Education (1)
Lin Feng-jeng (1)
Liu Ge-Zen (1)
March 1 2002 (1)
March 10 2003 (1)
March 11 2002 (1)
March 12 2006 (1)
March 15 2004 (1)
March 16 2005 (1)
March 18 2004 (2)
March 18 202 (1)
March 21 2007 (1)
March 22 2004 (1)
March 22 2007 (1)
March 24 2004 (1)
March 26 2010 (1)
March 28 2007 (1)
March 31 2000 (1)
March 5 2004 (1)
March 5 2009 (1)
May 13 2004 (2)
May 16 2003 (1)
May 17 2003 (2)
May 18 2003 (2)
May 18 2006 (2)
May 19 2003 (1)
May 19 2006 (5)
May 21 2010 (1)
May 22 2002 (2)
May 25 2004 (1)
May 28 2010 (1)
May 4 2002 (1)
May 6 2003 (1)
MOE (1)
National Taiwan University (1)
NCKU Faculty Union (1)
NCKU Presidential Search Committee (1)
NCKU Student Newspaper Report on the Illegal Dismissal Case at National Cheng Kung University (1)
News Item on NCKU Dismissal Case (1)
November 11 2003 (1)
November 17 2001 (1)
November 18 2001 (1)
November 22 2001 (2)
November 28 2007 (3)
November 6 2003 (4)
November 9 2003 (1)
October 1 2001 (1)
October 10 2007 (1)
October 11 2007 (1)
October 12 2003 (1)
October 13 2003 (3)
October 13 2009 (1)
October 14 2003 (1)
October 16 2003 (1)
October 18 2001 (1)
October 19 2007 (2)
October 2 2009 (1)
October 27 2006 (1)
October 29 2004 (1)
October 3 2005 (1)
October 5 2001 (1)
October 5 2009 (1)
October 6 2009 (2)
October 7 2009 (1)
October 8 2003 (1)
October 9 (1)
Office of Student Affairs (1)
Office of the President of Taiwan (1)
Ovid Tzeng (3)
Pix (2)
President's Office (1)
Prime Minister of Taiwan (2)
Purdue University Board of Trustees (1)
Purdue University President (1)
Raymond Lai (1)
Regarding Principles of Academic Exchanges with Sister Universities (5)
Richard Hazeldine (2)
Robert Chung (1)
Scholars at Risk (6)
Scholars at Risk (20)
Secretary-General (2)
Sept 2 2009 (1)
Sept 30 2009 (1)
Sept 4 2009 (1)
September 1 2003 (1)
September 16 2003 (1)
September 17 2005 (2)
September 19 2005 (1)
September 19 2006 (1)
September 2 2003 (1)
September 20 2001 (1)
September 22 2000 (1)
September 25 2000 (1)
September 26 2003 (2)
September 26 2005 (2)
September 27 2000 (2)
September 27 2001 (1)
September 27 2003 (2)
September 28 2007 (1)
September 29 2000 (1)
September 3 2003 (2)
September 30 2003 (2)
September 4 2000 (1)
September 4 2004 (1)
September 4 2009 (1)
September 5 2004 (1)
September 5 2009 (1)
Student Apology for Libelous Letter (1)
Student Misconduct (7)
Student Testimony (1)
Subornation of Students (1)
Summary of Human Rights Abuses at NCKU (6)
Taiwan Association for Human Rights (6)
Taiwan Department of Higher Education (4)
Taiwan Econcomi and Cultural Repreentative Office (TECRO) (1)
Taiwan Foundation for Democracy (1)
Taiwan Ministry of Education (54)
Taiwan Ministry of Education Warning Letters (2)
Taiwan Ministry of Foreign Affairs (1)
Taiwan Minstry of Education (1)
Teacher's Law (1)
Teachers Union Post (1)
Teaching Contract (1)
The China News (1)
The China Times (5)
The Control Yuan of Taiwan (2)
The Department of Academic Freedom and Tenure (1)
THE LIBERTY TIMES (3)
The Taipei Times (7)
Timeline (2)
Universal Declaration of Human Rights Article 8 (1)
University Misconduct (1)
Wikipedia Issue (2)
Yang Ming-Tzong (5)

Watermark theme. Powered by Blogger.